Claire Lynch Goes (A Little Bit) Country

Dear Sister - Claire LynchLet’s get the disclaimers out of the way right up front.

Yes, there are drums on many of the tracks on Claire Lynch’s Compass Records debut, Dear Sister. There’s also a Hammond B3 in a few places, though it’s hidden in the mix.

I don’t care.

And, yes, while The Claire Lynch Band has pushed the boundaries of bluegrass before, this one has more of a country sound than her recent projects.

I don’t care about that, either.

Here’s what I care about: Claire Lynch is singing on a new record. She could be accompanied by sandpaper and dental drills and I’d listen over and over again.

Fortunately, for those of us who love good music no matter which little box it fits into, she’s accompanied on this project by what just might be the best iteration of her band, which has always attracted great pickers over the years – Matt Wingate on guitar and mandolin, Bryan McDowell on fiddle and mandolin and Mark Schatz on the upright bass.

From start to finish, the band is tight and Garry West’s production shines. But that’s all gravy to accompany the main dish – one of the best voices in bluegrass, any era, any gender. (I’d put Dale Ann Bradley in that category, too, which is the only reason Claire doesn’t have a lock on IBMA’s female vocalist award year after year.)

From the opening lines of How Many Moons, Claire uses her voice to wring the emotion out of every song. There’s loneliness in Need Someone and Everybody Knows I’ve Been Crying. There’s triumph in That Kind of Love. There’s the anguish of love gone cold in Once the Teardrops Start to Fall. And there’s a bit of arrogance in the Bobby Osborne-Pete Gobel classic, I’ll Be Alright Tomorrow.

But the title cut seals the deal on this project. Dear Sister is a co-write with Louisa Branscomb, whose ancestors wrote their sister back home in Alabama as they fought, valiantly but in vain for the South during the Civil War. The chilling song – “This could be my last letter. I may never see the cotton fields of home again” – has its roots in the preserved letters of Louisa’s kin, which were recounted in a book written by her cousin, Frank Anderson Chappel, also called Dear Sister. It’s far and away the best of the 10 cuts on the CD.

The only weak link in the chain is the closing medley of Buttermilk Road and The Arbours, a tune written by Mark Schatz. I’ve heard the band do this live, and it’s terrific, but clogging and hambone don’t translate quite as well on a recording.

The big question about Dear Sister is how much airplay it will get. Dear Sister and I’ll Be Alright Tomorrow will be in regular rotation, for sure. But some of the other cuts are probably a bit too country for bluegrass radio and don’t, I’m happy to say, have the heavy pop flavor that’s dominant in what passes for country music these days.

But Claire Lynch has paid her dues. She’s earned the chance to make whatever kind of record she wants to make.

And no matter what you call it, she’s made a very good one.

Share this:

About the Author

David Morris

David Morris, an award-winning songwriter and journalist, has written for Bluegrass Today since its inception. He joined its predecessor, The Bluegrass Blog, in 2010. His 40-year career in journalism included more than 13 years with The Associated Press, a stint as chief White House correspondent for Bloomberg News, and several top editing jobs in Washington, D.C. He is a life member of IBMA and the DC Bluegrass Union. He and co-writers won the bluegrass category in the Chris Austin Songwriting Contest at MerleFest in 2015.

  • Katie Litteral

    “Buttermilk Road” a weak chain? Whaaah? Besides the title cut that’s my favorite track (along with “Patch of Blue”). But then again I’ve probably seen them perform it about half a dozen times live, and it’s always my favorite then, love the clogging and Martha Scanlan’s poem-like lyrics. There’s still the lyrics even if you say the hambone&clogging don’t record well (which I think they do fine, they’re just not as prominent). Was thrilled to have it included on the new album. – Just sayin’…

  • David Morris

    Katie, it’s a wonderful medley and, as I said, it’s a great live performance. Mark is an amazing performer. I just didn’t think it was as strong on the record, especially for listeners who don’t have the memories of the live performance and Mark’s energy and expressions to fall back on. That doesn’t diminish my overall opinion of the album, or the fact that I could listen to Claire sing the phone book.

  • fdwil111

    I do love Claire Lynch (my Alabama songbird), but I’m disappointed with this project. This is due to the song selection and my expectations. The songs are mostly out of my zone. Now, Alison and Union Station also push the envelope of my comfort zone but I leave knowing why they are trying this direction with their music. I don’t understand this with the selections on the Dear Sister collection. Sorry to be a naysayer. Also, the release of other new CDs by Dailey and Vincent, the Gibson Brothers, Doyle Lawson and Newton and Thomas, etc have set the bar very high in both outside-the box song selection and arrangement/performance. BUT, I’ll look forward to the next project.

    • Katie Litteral

      First of all I’m truly sorry you feel that way Fred. Secondly, would you mind Claireifying (sorry, couldn’t help it) for us what exactly your “zone” is and what you don’t understand about the track selections? – Did you like any of them best?

      • Darren Sullivan-Koch

        Wow. God forbid anyone express their opinion.

  • fdwil111


    It’s an opinion. I had read your first post and I knew your opinion was different. To try to dig deeper, the song selection seems to be for the band members to shine rather than for the sound of the entire group. Of course that’s another opinion I’m expressing here. I’m really not trying to change your mind about the CD. My picks are I’ll Be Alright Tomorrow; Once The Teardrops Start To Fall and How Many Moons (but for that one the White’s version still floats my boat).